Nana's Commentary:
Of all the Western Holidays in full swing in American culture, Thanksgiving is one of the hardest ones for me to decline participation in. I thoroughly love the harvest foods that are part of the celebration, although lately, Turkey has become Murkey in that it does not have the same tastes as it once did while I was growing up. It's mushy and has little or no flavor. Poor boogers probably never see the light of day. Makes you wonder how many Turkeys have to die in order to keep this Holiday going.
It was also one of the few times, that my Mother cooked a full delicious meal, with the sweet potato casserole covered with marshmallows. I remember stuffing myself till I could barely stand, and Mom would always say, "I cooked, you get to wash the dishes." That only applied when it was her turn to cook.
Then one day, it was revealed to me, what really happened and that made a significant difference in my perspective of this beloved Holiday. I guess we could rationalize and say, well, it ain't happening now, now we can re-invent it and make it stand for something good instead. But it always seemed a selective amnesia for certain things and for other things, and events, well, nobody forgets those.
So, for many, many years now, I decline to celebrate. I remain thankful all year round, hardly ever eat turkey and just wish we had a more peaceful world to live in.
For those of you who are out there, I wish you safe travels. be careful and remember that Thanksgiving is a very wonderful thing to do on a daily basis!
Thanksgiving: Celebrating all that we have,
and the genocide it took to get it.
Thanksgiving
is one of the most paradoxical times of the year. We gather together with
friends and family in celebration of all that we are thankful for and express
our gratitude, at the same time we are encouraged to eat in excess. But the
irony really starts the next day on Black Friday. On Thursday we appreciate
all the simple things in life, such as having a meal, a roof over our head,
and the connection with those close to us. But in less than 24 hours, we
literally trample over others in a mad dash to accumulate as many material
possessions as possible at bargain-prices.
So what is the true history of
Thanksgiving? Well, just like we have stories of Easter in which a
magical bunny hops around the world and hides baskets of goodies for us to
find, or stories of Christmas where Santa Claus travels the globe in one
night to leave presents under the tree for good boys and girls –
Thanksgiving, too, has its traditional myth which we share with our children.
We recount stories of the Indians and Pilgrims getting together for
a magical feast of brotherly love and appreciation. The only problem is
that, unlike the other holidays, we never reveal the truth about Thanksgiving
to our children as they grow older. In fact, most of us don’t understand
its bloody history ourselves…
The
first actual proclaimed “Day of Thanksgiving” came in 1637 in a meeting
between the Pequot Indians and English religious mercenaries. The Pequot were
celebrating their annual Green Harvest Festival, which resembles modern-day
Thanksgiving. On the eve of the festival, the English demanded that everyone
comes out of their homes, puts their weapons on the ground, and surrenders by
converting to Christianity.
Those
who obliged with these terroristic demands were either shot dead or clubbed to
death. Those who stayed inside their longhouses – including women and children
– were burnt to death. In all, more than 700 Pequot men, women, and children
were slaughtered that day.
The
“victory” was celebrated by the Governor of Massachusetts Bay Colony holding a
feast and trumpeted this as a “Day of Thanksgiving.” During the celebration,
they cut off heads of Natives and put them on display publicly; including
beheading the Wampanoag Chief and impaling his head on a pole in Plymouth
which stayed on display for the next 24 years.
New
Family Values
I was
in third grade and playing in my back yard, when I noticed a moving truck in
the parking lot beyond the fence. We lived in a middle-class suburban
community, but right beyond our fenced in yard, there was a Section 8 Housing
Community.
As I
stood and watched, a young boy around my age came running over to the fence to
greet me.
“Hi,
My Name is Doug,” he said, “We are moving in next door.”
It’s
funny as kids, we are so free and we see someone our age and we just want to
be friends. Someone we can spend time with. This shows the natural desire of
human connection.
Doug
and I became pretty good friends instantly. We spent time at each other’s
house often, mostly playing Nintendo or throwing the ball around in the yard.
Until
one day, one of my favorite video games was missing. No idea what happened,
but the game was gone. We always had anywhere from three to 10 people over at
our house and there is no way of knowing what happened to the game or if it
was simply misplaced.
“No
more going over to that Indian’s house,” my Dad told me, “He took your game.”
Indian?
What’s an Indian? I remember thinking that to myself. To me, Doug was just my
friend. Now, just like that, he was my Indian-friend. I knew very little about
other races at that time. Sure, we saw that people looked different, but never
attached a label like that.
The
only thing I knew about Indians, I learned in school. And the things I learned
in school, was just being passed down from what our teacher’s learned in
school with no adjustments to the curriculum. We learned how to sit
“Indian-Style,” we learned how to sing “Ten Little Indians,” learned what it
meant to be called an “Indian-Giver,” and we learned to play “Cowboys and
Indians.”
I can
honestly remember in First or Second grade around Thanksgiving, we made
headdresses and colored feathers to dress up like Indians. Then they told us
how to do war-cries by putting your hand over your mouth and yelling,
“Ahh-Ahh-Ooh-Ooh.”
They
instructed the class that the Pilgrims came over from Europe to escape
religious persecution. Upon arriving in America, they realized that there were
already people living here. The brave Europeans encountered the Indians, who
wore headdresses, make weird noises, and were uncivilized. So, the
Pilgrims
decided to help them out and they had a giant feast together. Everyone got
along and then for every year since then, we celebrate Thanksgiving.
But,
Doug didn’t do any of those things. I never met an Indian, he was just a
normal kid. But, I was told not to trust him. The irony of a white person not
trusting an Indian is too much to even comprehend.
“Doug,
do you have my video game?” I asked him, “And, I am not allowed to come over
here anymore and you can’t come over to my house.”
“No,
I don’t have it. Why would I take it? You always let me use it whenever I
want,” he replied, “But I understand. I won’t come over anymore.”
As
the next couple years went by, I start seeing more movies with Cowboys and
Indians with the natives viewed as hostile savages and the cowboys save the
country. I am now in fifth grade and have been trained and brainwashed to hate
a race of people and believe that I am good and they are wrong. And, still no
one has given me an answer as to what happened to all the Indians that lived
here?
Then,
I gained perspective from the oddest of sources – the comedy movie, “Addams
Family Values.” In the movie, the children were at some type of summer
camp in which they are putting on a play for their parents, reenacting the
first Thanksgiving. All the rich-white privileged kids at the camp were
playing the role of the wholesome pilgrims; whereas, the outcasts of the camp
were stuck playing the part of the “uncivilized” Indians. As the pilgrims
invited the Indians for a meal together, Wednesday Addams –playing the role of
Pocahontas (although this is historically inaccurate as Pocahontas lived near
the Jamestown Settlement) – decides to go off the script just prior to sitting
down for the meal:
“Wait, we can not break bread with you. You have taken
the land which is rightfully ours. Years from now my people will be forced to
live in mobile homes on reservations. Your people will wear cardigans, and
drink highballs. We will sell our bracelets by the road sides, and you will
play golf. My people will have pain and degradation. Your people will have
stick shifts. The gods of my tribe have spoken. They said do not trust the
pilgrims. And especially do not trust Sarah Miller. For all these reasons I
have decided to scalp you and burn your village to the ground.” [view scene]
I
remember watching this scene and my friends were laughing hysterically, but
not me. I was more in shock and awe. It all made sense. I realized that
everything I had been told about history was a lie. And I have been searching
for the truth ever since.
A
National Day of Mourning
We
are very impressionable as children and take what elders, parents, and
teachers tell us as fact. It gets very difficult to break these thoughts that
shape our identity. However, the story of Thanksgiving described above has
only a small semblance of truth. The Pilgrims and Indians got together for a
giant feast – one time. And in all recorded history of that time, there are
actually only two documents of record reporting this event, over the total of
three paragraphs – indicating the very minor significant of this event.
Thanksgiving
Day is also known as The National Day of Mourning among Native American
Tribes. In 1970, there was a huge celebration in Massachussets to celebrate
the 350th anniversary of the landing of the Pilgrims. Today, there are
still Wampanoags living in the area. On the day of the celebration, they asked
one of them to speak:
“Today is a time of celebrating for you — a time of looking
back to the first days of white people in America. But it is not a time of
celebrating for me. It is with a heavy heart that I look back upon what
happened to my People. When the Pilgrims arrived, we, the Wampanoags, welcomed
them with open arms, little knowing that it was the beginning of the end. That
before 50 years were to pass, the Wampanoag would no longer be a tribe. That
we and other Indians living near the settlers would be killed by their guns or
dead from diseases that we caught from them. Let us always remember, the
Indian is and was just as human as the white people.
Although
our way of life is almost gone, we, the Wampanoags, still walk the lands of
Massachusetts. What has happened cannot be changed. But today we work toward a
better America, a more Indian America where people and nature once again are
important.”
The
National Day of Mourning plaque at Plymouth, Massachusetts
The
Lies of Thanksgiving
To
get started, the Pilgrims were not seeking religious persecution – they
already had that in Holland by 1608. However, they did not like the work and
demands of Holland and wanted to seek commercial ventures overseas. However
the Pilgrims also had no money or resources, so they had to borrow a loan from
the Virginia Company of London and Plymouth. The agreement stated that they
were to take all the money earned over the first seven years and put it into a
common stock – sounds like Communism.
So,
the communist Pilgrims sailed across the sea in September of 1620. Yet, it is
also important to note that they did not call themselves Pilgrims. They were
originally referred to as Separatists as they no longer followed the Church of
England. Yet, they referred to themselves as God’s Chosen People, in which
they called themselves “Saints.”
The
rest of England, considered them “religious dropouts.”
The
Pilgrims were also not farmers, nor woodsmen; they were mostly city people and
artisans that had no clue how to survive in the Wilderness. It would be like
if a group of broke-hipsters decided to move to a remote jungle in South
America to start their own civilization because they do not fit in with
mainstream society. Yet, they don’t have money, so they take out a loan from
the government to set up their little expedition.
They
were not just being persecuted for religious beliefs either, they were
revolutionaries who intended – and in fact, did in 1649 – overthrow the
English Government.
On
November 20, 1620, they landed at Cape Cod – not Plymouth Rock. A winter storm
had sent them off-course and they were many miles north of their destination
in Virginia. They landed in a desolated area in which the Patuxet used to live
– but were completely wiped away by disease in 1617. The Pilgrims raided the
land for corn, beans, and robbed the gravesites at Corn Hill to steal as much
winter provisions as they could handle.
It
wasn’t until another month later that they landed at Plymouth Rock. In which,
the crew was decimated and the settlers were either dead or dying from
starvation, malnutrition and disease. Only 53 of the remaining 102 members of
this ship made it through the winter. In March, they were greeted by two
English-Speaking Indians – Samoset and Squanto.
While
this tale seems miraculous, in fact Plymouth Governor Bradford referred to
Squanto as “a special instrument sent from God.” However, it was not that
simple.
Squanto
had been captured in 1605 and sold into slavery in England, in which he was
forced to learn English. Then they sent him back to America, only to serve as
a guide for the explorers to further ravage his land. In 1614, he was captured
again and shipped to Spain. This time “rescued” by friars who tried to control
the slaves and convert them to Christianity. He jump-shipped again and made
his way back to his homeland in 1619, only to see that every member of his
tribe had perished to disease. Hence, Squanto was the last living Patuxet and
was forced to live with the nearby Wampanoag.
This
is the man that helped the Pilgrims survive – enslaved twice, forced to learn
English, attempted to be forced to convert to Christianity, then to return
home and find everyone he loved was dead. If it were not for Squanto, all
historians agree that the Pilgrims would have starved to death and had quite a
different impact on American history.
As
Governor Bradford explained:
“Squanto continued with them and was their interpreter and was
a special instrument sent of God for their good beyond their expectation. He
directed them how to set their corn, where to take fish, and to procure other
commodities, and was also their pilot to bring them to unknown places for
their profit, and never let them till he died.”
The
Pilgrims were living in dirt-covered shelters, had no food, and nearly half of
them had died during the winter. They obviously needed help and the two men
were a welcome sight. Squanto, who probably knew more English than any other
Indian in North America at that time, decided to stay with the Pilgrims for
the next few months and teach them how to survive in this new place.
Squanto
had orchestrated a treaty between the Pilgrims and Indians to protect each
other from neighboring tribes.
By
Fall of 1621, things had greatly improved for the Pilgrims. They put together
a feast to celebrate their harvest – a common custom of the day in all parts
of the world. This was celebrated back in Europe for many years, as well as
the local tribes had six different “Thanksgiving” feasts throughout the year.
As
they Pilgrims were shooting their guns in the air – likely with a mixture of
the hefty amounts of alcohol they consumed – they were met by ninety or more
Wampanoags. As the story goes, they invited the Indians to join them. However,
it is more likely that the Indians rushed over to see what all the gunfire was
about and then were asked to join. They had a three-day feast, in which the
Indians provided the majority of the food.
This
was never called “Thanksgiving” and it was not the beginning of some beautiful
friendship, in which they all lived happily ever after. In fact, it never
happened again. This was the first, and only, time that they got together in
peace. The true “First Thanksgiving” was a much bloodier hell on Earth which
tells the tale of the next 400 years for the Native Americans.
The
“First Thanksgiving”
It is
hard to tell the true intention of the first Pilgrims at Plymouth as they were
severely outnumbered and had no means of survival in the New World. Once word
was spread about the Paradise out West, more and more religious zealots, known
as Puritans, came sweeping across the shores of America.
Once
they arrived, they noticed no fences around the land and considered it all to
be public domain. They were not in as great need of help from the Natives, as
the original Pilgrims, and the friendship between the two weakened rapidly.
Soon, the Pilgrims were demeaning the Indians for their religious beliefs and
the children of those who shared this majestic meal together were killing each
other in the next generation’s King Phillip’s War.
That
is the foundation of America’s idea of “freedom.” We want freedom for
ourselves, but not for those who do not look, think, act, and believe as we
do. In the Declaration of Independence it is stated that “All Men Are Created
Equal” but each of the founding fathers were slave-owners who valued white
supremacy and favored Indian genocide. They didn’t want equality, they just
wanted equality from the British, but the oppression they did to
African-Americans, Indians, and Women was completely acceptable.
The
Pilgrims were religious bigots who saw themselves as the “chosen elect” and
first planned to purify themselves and then anyone who did not accept their
interpretation of scripture. They believed they were fighting a holy war
against Satan. In a “Thanksgiving” sermon in 1623, Maher the Elder gave
special thanks for destroying “chiefly young men and children, the very seeds
of increase, thus cleaning the forests to make way for a better growth.” Yes,
thanking the Lord for giving smallpox to the same Wampanoag that saved them
from starvation two years prior.
In
1637, as stated in the opening paragraphs of this article, the first
Thanksgiving was held to celebrate the systematic slaughtering of the “heathen
savages.” These killings become more and more, as the settlers went from
village to village wiping out generations of tribes. With each “victory” they
would hold days of thanksgiving feasts for each successful massacre.
During
the next century, the Tribes continued to get pushed further West. The likes
of Lord Jeffrey Amherst intentionally gave smallpox-infested blankets to
tribes in the early forms of biological warfare. Whereas, the 1756 Indian
Scalp Act paid out bounties for the scalps of Indian men, women, and children.
This
continued up through the French-Indian War in which the British defeated the
Indian-French allies; but proclaimed that the settlers can not go West of the
Appalachian Mountains – not because they grew a heart for the Indians –but
because it would be too hard to manage the settlers which would soon revolt
against the Kingdom.
Even
during the Revolutionary War, there were Days of Thanksgiving honored after a
victory against the British. Until George Washington suggested that there is
only one day of Thanksgiving set aside per year, rather than after each
massacre.
The
“Most Free Country on Earth”
After
being declared a “free country,” the savagery continued. President Andrew
Jackson issued the Indian Removal Act of 1830, which forced the Natives west
to Oklahoma. The Cherokee removal from Tennessee became known as the infamous
“Trail of Tears” in which Cherokee were slain in front of family members if
they did not oblige.
As
the land continued to be stolen, the Native Americans set up reservations.
This land was not GIVEN to the Native Americans, it is land that THEY reserved
for themselves that could not be taken from them. However, as we find out that
did not seem to matter as the United States has broken every treaty ever
signed with a Native American tribe.
It’s
also important to understand that the government does not just hand out money
“because they are Indians.” They are given money that is owed to them due to
the treaties signed by the United States to purchase their land, and they
settlements due to breaking every single treaty ever signed. It is not just a
charity hand-out, it is part of a guilty plea.
However,
false propaganda and poor educational curriculum like to inform the mainstream
that we “gave the Indians reservations” and “pay them money.” This ignorance
is a direct result of America not teaching their children what a treaty
actually entails, or why it was signed in the first place.
In
1851, the Sioux made two treaties in which they were to be compensated with
cash, food, and goods to give up over one-million acres of land to the United
States, while living on the reservation. However, there were corrupt leaders
in the Bureau of Indian Affairs who refused payments and gave goods out to
white settlers instead. Once Minnesota became a state, Chief Little Crow took
his grievances to Washington – in return, the United States took half of the
land back from the Sioux and opened it up for white expansion.
Each
year the situation got worse, until the summer of 1862 in which the Sioux were
literally starving in these unlivable situations. This is referred to in
history as the “Sioux Uprising.” They were “uprising” because you were
starving them to death because of lies and broken promises.
One
day a group went off the reservation hunting and stole some eggs from white
settlers and eventually murdered them. The authorities in Minnesota then
rounded up 303 Sioux, many of which were not involved in the uprising, and
sentenced them to be hung to death. The Great Emancipator, President Abraham
Lincoln issued the largest mass-killing in American history with the hanging
of 38 Santee Sioux in Mankato, Minnesota. He reduced the number to 38 in fear
that European nations may take the side of the South in the Civil War and
exchange he promised Minnesota to kill or remove any Indians from Minnesota
and pay $2 million in settlement – he only owed the Sioux$1.4 million for the
land.
One
year later, Congress expunged all Sioux treaties from the records, took back
their reserved land and ordered the entire tribe to be expelled from
Minnesota. As an incentive, a bounty of $25 was offered for the scalp of any
Sioux found living in the state. In the same year, President Lincoln decided
that Thanksgiving should be a Federal Holiday.
During
this time, the Wild-Wild West included the likes of Custer going from
camp-to-camp killing Indian women, men, and children for sport. They would
burn, rape, and mutilate entire villages and were celebrated in the news as
heroes. This includes his raid of the sleeping Cheyenne and their peace Chief
Black Kettle, despite his previous surrender to the military and willingness
to live on the reservations.
In
1890, on the Pine Ridge Reservation the Natives were practicing ghost dances,
in which the military was called in and turned a peaceful dance into a
massacre with another 300 dead at the hands of their conquerors.
“The people who are citizens of the U.S., these are your
treaties. They aren’t just the Indians’ treaties. No one gave us
anything. No one was dragging any land behind them when they came here. This
was our land… As native American peoples in this red corner of Mother Earth,
we have no reason to celebrate an invasion that caused the demise of so many
of our people, and is still causing destruction today.” ~ Suzan
Shown Harjo, the Morning Star Institute, a national Native American rights
organization.
Boarding Schools
As
the Sioux Wars ended, and it wasn’t as easy to deliberately kill the Indians,
the Americans needed a new way to carry out genocide. They introduced the
Boarding School System in 1890. This was United States Government policy that
they could show up at your doorstep, take away your infants and toddlers and
ship them to boarding schools hundreds of miles away. Your children were
no longer yours.
At
these schools they were banned to speak native languages, mocked their
traditions and cultures, cut their hair, made them look American, as well as
physically, emotionally, and sexually abused on a daily basis. Some children
would never see their parents again. Or if they did, they had become different
people.
It
was a systematic eradicating of a race of people, they looked Indian but they
were Americanizing them. Every Indian today is a product of this boarding
school system. It peaked in the 1970s and carried into the 21st century.
In
the 1950s, the United States then wanted to “re-civilize” the Indians and
invited them to live back in the city. The problem is they had no money,
education, or skills, and could not find work. Most of them ended up homeless
or in jail.
Primitive
Savages
There
are volumes and volumes of dissertations written on this information listed
above and it is difficult to condense it to less than a couple thousand words.
(I encourage you to do you own research.) But in reading through the horrors,
atrocities, genocide, and institutionalized racism enacted against the
indigenous people, what is quite clear is that the label of ‘savages’ is
on the wrong end.
Our
society’s practice of “might is right”, consumerism, competition, separation
and judgment is the opposite of how humans were designed to live. We were
meant to live in harmony with each other and respect our fellow man. These
ideas and values had already been in place for many years, but have been since
removed by an advanced military society, but a primitive spiritual one.
“When your people came to our land, it was not with open arms,
but with Bibles and guns and disease. You took our land. You killed us with
your guns and disease, then had the arrogance to call us godless savages. If
there is a Heaven and it is filled with Christians, than Hell is the place for
me.”
Primitive
spirituality and genocidal practices over the past four-hundred years have
resulted in nearly 100 million deaths of indigenous people – making the
Europeans the true primitive savages. Before the European invasion of the
Americas, there were believed to be as many as 80-100 million native people
occupying what is now the United States. According to the 2010 U.S. Census,
only 5.2 million people in the U.S. identified as American Indian and
Alaskan Native, either wholly or in part, and out of this total only 2.9
million people identified as solely American Indian or Alaska
Native. At the time of European invasion, at least 300
different languages were spoken in addition to numerous “trade languages”.
The natives
of the Americas were not only “living lightly on the land”, as is so often
claimed, but were engaged in landscaping, building and agriculture, trade and
commerce, in addition to sustainable hunting and gathering, and of
course, ancient cultural and earth-based spiritual practices — much of
which has now been decimated.
When
Christopher Columbus first landed in the Americas, ho entered an occupied land
with force to subjugate and exterminate the civilizations that had existed
for at least 30,000 years
(some estimates are as high as 200,000 years), a trend that continued for
several hundred years. And although he and the colonists that arrived in
the years to follow have become icons of our national
mythology, the result has been mass assimilation, raping, slaughtering,
enslaving, and intention to wipe out all evidence of a native population of
between 50 and 100 million
indigenous people from the land — the greatest genocide in
recorded history.
But,
one day out of the year, we are able to give thanks and show gratitude as part
of the traditional celebration to honor a bloody massacre.
About
the Author
An avid historian, Irwin Ozborne (a pen-name) is a
survivor of childhood abuse and torture over a period of 13 years, and a
recovered alcoholic. As a mental health practitioner, today Irwin practices
holistic care and incorporates eastern philosophy into his work with clients.
He is available for speaking engagements as well, and can be contacted via
email: takingmaskoff@yahoo.com. Please visit www.takingthemaskoff.com.
